Other pressure-based flow elements exist as alternatives to the orifice plate. The Pitot tube, for example, senses pressure as the fluid stagnates (comes to a complete stop) against the open end of a forward-facing tube. A shortcoming of the classic single-tube Pitot assembly is sensitivity to the fluid velocity at just one point in the pipe, so a more common form of Pitot tube seen in the industry is the averaging Pitot tube consisting of several stagnation holes sensing velocity at multiple points across the width of the flow:
A
variation on the latter theme is the Annubar flow element, a trade name of the
Dieterich Standard corporation. An “Annubar” is an averaging pitot tube
consolidating high and low pressure sensing ports in a single probe assembly:
What
appears at first glance to be a single, square-shaped tube inserted into the
pipe is actually a double-ported tube with holes on both the upstream and
downstream edges:
A section of Annubar tube clearly shows the porting and dual chambers, designed to bring upstream (stagnation) and downstream pressures out of the pipe to a differential pressure-sensing instrument:
A less
sophisticated realization of the stagnation principle is the target flow
sensor, consisting of a blunt “paddle” (or “drag disk”) inserted into the flow
stream. The force exerted on this paddle by the moving fluid is sensed by a special
transmitter mechanism, which then outputs a signal corresponding to flow rate
(proportional to the square of fluid velocity, just like an orifice plate):
The
classic venturi tube pioneered by Clemens Herschel in 1887 has been adapted in
a variety of forms broadly classified as flow tubes. All flow tubes work on the
same principle: developing a differential pressure by channeling fluid flow
from a wide tube to a narrow tube. The difference from the classic venturi is only in
construction details, the most significant detail is a significantly shorter
length than the classic venturi tube. Examples of flow tube designs include the
Dall tube, Lo-Loss flow tube, Gentile or Bethlehem flow tube, and the B.I.F.
Universal Venturi.
Another
variation on the venturi theme is called a flow nozzle, designed to be clamped
between the faces of two pipe flanges in a manner similar to an orifice plate.
The goal here is to achieve simplicity of installation approximating that of an
orifice plate while improving performance (less permanent pressure loss) over
orifice plates:
Two
more variations on the venturi theme are the V-cone and Segmental wedge flow
elements. The V-cone (or “venturi cone,” a trade name of the McCrometer
division of the Danaher Corporation) may be thought of as a venturi tube or
orifice plate in reverse17: instead of narrowing the tube’s diameter to cause
fluid acceleration, the fluid must flow around a cone-shaped obstruction placed in
the middle of the tube. The tube’s effective area will be reduced by the
presence of this cone, causing fluid to accelerate through the restriction just
as it would through the throat of a classic venturi tube:
This
cone is hollow, with a pressure-sensing port on the downstream side allowing
for easy detection of fluid pressure near the vena contracta. Upstream pressure
is sensed by another port in the pipe wall upstream of the cone. The following
photograph shows a V-cone flow tube, cutaway for demonstration purposes:
Segmental
wedge elements are special pipe sections with wedge-shaped restrictions built-in. These devices, albeit crude, are useful for measuring the flow rates of
slurries, especially when pressure is sensed by the transmitter through
remote-seal diaphragms (to eliminate the possibility of impulse tube plugging):
Finally,
the lowly pipe elbow may be pressed into service as a flow-measuring element,
since fluid turning a corner in the elbow experiences radial acceleration and
therefore generates a differential pressure along the axis of acceleration:
Pipe elbows should be considered for flow measurement only as a last resort. Their inaccuracies tend to be extreme, owing to the non-precise construction of most pipe elbows and the relatively weak differential pressures generated.
A
final point should be mentioned on the subject of differential-producing
elements, and that is their energy dissipation. Orifice plates are simple and
relatively inexpensive to install, but their permanent pressure loss is high
compared with other primary elements such as venturi tubes. Permanent pressure
loss is permanent energy loss from the flow stream, which usually represents a
loss in the energy invested into the process by pumps, compressors, and/or blowers.
Fluid energy dissipated by an orifice plate thus (usually) translates into a
requirement of greater energy input to that process.
With
the financial and ecological costs of energy being non-trivial in our modern
world, it is important to consider energy loss as a significant factor in
choosing the appropriate primary element for a pressure-based flowmeter. It
might very well be that an “expensive” venturi tube saves more money in the
long term than a “cheap” orifice plate, while delivering greater measurement
accuracy as an added benefit.
List
of Prominent Manufacturers: ABB, Arthur Grillo, Dwyer, Emerson, Fuji Electric, General Instruments, Krohne, Mega System, PIC,
PS Instruments, Sauermann, Sunflow Technologies, Texense, WIKA
Follow
to get new posts and updates about the blog. Appreciate your feedback!
No comments:
Post a Comment